|
Window wall leaked
Shortly after the window wall was completed (six months or so), we started getting puddles in the house when rain hit the south window wall. Additionally, the black slate which bridged from the new radiant floor to the window wall covering the remaining grey concrete footing started to pull up. There were several contributing factors: wood choice, letting it weather naturally (not my idea) and not being designed to prevent water flow through the core infrastructure. The architect even designed the glass to be set from the inside! This led to water hitting the glass, rolling down and then under the trim used to set the glass and into the house. The leaks were coming from multiple places. No efforts by the construction manager helped.
Pool would not hold water
My housemates made fun of me on a local Madison, WI. talk show for not providing the hot tub which was sitting there needing to be finished still in 1985. I made sure the mechanicals were set and paid for a tile pattern from the Wright hotel that had been built in Japan was installed. We were finally going to be able to enjoy this last piece and enjoy our reflecting pool or so I thought. We fired it up and filled it up and hopped in. Sadly, it turned out it leaked 2 inches an hour. If you do the calculations based on a 4.5-foot radius you get 79 gallons per hour were leaking.
Enough
The following photos were part of the documentation done prior to the lawsuit of the construction manager and to document the last step of my restoration work where the pool held water in, and the window wall held water out. This did not seem too much to ask for the funds that had been spent to restore the house.
Pools
Why: This last item was the last straw. I located a pool specialist and had Gary (AAA) dig under the new radiant floor and ensured the plumbing was not the issue. My pool specialist said duh. Why did you have basement folks do a pool and in three pours yet. This was true. The first pour defined the inside curve by the pour of the radiant floor. This was a critical design element and had to be restored. The second pour was a thickening of the wall between the two pools which would add insulation and a ledge suitable for the new shade system to seal against. The last pour created a bench and a floor to the pool. He said it was leaking from all the pour seams. Remember that nice tile work I had just paid for (the tiling)? Gone as part of the process to determine the fix.
Here I am adding the trim rings onto the jets after finally completely equipping and tiling the new inside pool. My change here highlighted the semi-circular design element with an older Frank Lloyd Wright tile pattern and ensured no one would ever suffer from trying to manage an inside fish pool. That had been nice but an extremely miserable task to maintain. As the Moores have done and I also did, the circle area made a great place for an inside plant gathering. There is nothing better for plants than a southern exposure.
It was so sad to see it in this condition. The pool person was good and after fixing seams and adding another short pour to have the floor in fact overlap the walls, the pool was fixed. In this photo you can see the two pipes which could heat and filter the outside pool. Oh, and that is not a clean window between the pools, it is my first wall being torn out. Eventually it looked like the previous photo.
South Solar WallTo resolve the window wall issues, I met with an old neighbor (Howard Mazur) who had been an owner of a large Madison, WI home building company. He got me two things: a skilled architect (Gary Brink) and an incredible two-person crew. The wall could not be saved along with much of the glass. The glass issue was due to design changes to allow no water to flow through wall. The new structure meant the glass sizes changed. This was quite expensive as code for glass near doors was required to be tempered.
My first born
We started ripping out the first solar wall in August of 1985. By the time Christie was born September 1, the front of the house was all plastic again. We moved into a two-room suite at a local motel for the first two weeks as new parents. After that time, Barb and Christie spent most of their time in the master bedroom closet. It is funny how all projects are estimated at two weeks and always take much longer. Living conditions had traversals down to the kitchen as the only area we were then using. A second area of plastic ran along the balcony rail trying to keep the sawdust and other smells out of the upstairs. We lived upstairs except for when we used the kitchen.
Wall one during removal
There was never a motion to curtail the costs of the project. I had wanted a quality job to do justice to the design and the house’s history as one of many of Wright’s firsts. First home after WWII and first of his hemicycle designs. Seriously, why were not clear lumber chosen. The total savings for the project was to do all the related work at the same time. So, we did the new radiant floor, new window wall, mechanical changes, rafter rework for snow load building codes circa 1982, all new windows, fix and augment skylights, upgrade kitchen, restore balcony partitions and lots of small stuff.
I was told later that almost the entire design invited water to just flow in. It is sad, but when you expect quality and are waiting for glass in your home everything looks better before aging. I am not sure where the construction manager got the SW-Team. I had heard rumors they had been unemployed (as carpenters?).
Seriously, this is a two-year-old wall. It was not helped by the fact I wanted to stain it right away as I had done to the original window wall many times. I still remember the project manager saying Wright would have wanted me to let it weather naturally. Well, it sure did.
Shoddy work and bad lumber choices were contributing factors. However, you can see from the damage all the way through the trim pieces holding the glass when it was set, there was a major and sustained leakage problem. Where did the construction manager find his architect?
The photo above was after the trim pieces were removed so the set glass could be removed before the rest of the wall. You are looking from inside the house. They set the glass from the inside! You just don’t do that, or it hits the glass and rolls under the glass and into the inside of the house. It is obvious that we were dealing with massive damage everywhere.
There was just no saving it.
Wall two (here we go again)
Gary (architect #2) was an excellent architect who knew all the issues with the first design. At every step of his design, the wood layers in the wall exposed a wood front designed to prevent water throughput. He also had the glass now going to be set properly from the outside. I came across a bit of luck and acquired enough clear redwood to not only build the new wall but also complete valances and tracks for the automated south window wall shade system.
Here we have some of the partially prepared clear redwood which was to be a major component of the second window wall. I was not going to let others make material choices for one of the premier design elements in the house. As you can see, the kitchen was left alone. The rest of the downstairs was wood shop, stacks of materials, consolidated furnishings tucked as far back as possible, and other items.
We pretreated much of the internally exposed wall components with Danish Oil as I had done with the new balcony partitions. Seeing the wood coming to life was a wonderful hint of things to come.
In this photo several things can be seen by yet another store of redwood for the wall. You can see 6 of the seven motorized shades also ready to finally be installed. There are four on the floor in the back and another two off on the right with one standing up on the other. The end design was a loop of textured shade cloth with a single sheet of reflective foil down the center. A wooden pole floated free during progress either up or down to make the roll/unroll process smooth and even.
The lower boxing to the new wall would then have covers with no travel path for the water to come through the wall. We were able to preserve most of the new infrastructure of the house defined by the double 2x6s which were at the core of the first window wall. They can be seen here as the new wall sits in a partial state. I want to call your attention to the furniture like quality of the window frames partially constructed and awaiting installation in the back of this picture.
Hey, at least we had a nice working kitchen during construction which I failed to have available in the first phase of the restoration work in 1982.
The rest of the 1500 square feet radiant main floor was working space and materials. Having the open area, I had created upstairs, provided us with a nice lounging space despite the plastic sheeting blocking the view south.
I made sure to minimize time as possible by moving ahead with things we could do then towards having a finished motorized shade system by the time the wall was done. Here you can see the wiring is now in place.
Again, the inner wall structure was designed to be both strong and unfriendly to water passage through it. Smart choices were made on portions of the wall being treated to the redwood. The design was intended for long-term stability which has certainly proven true.
And of course, we had curious visitors during construction.
|