House Condition Spring 1982

 

Radiant Floor

 

The floor pipes had known breaks. It was predictable that there would be further bursts from water which did not drain completely and had surely frozen over the two winters the house had sat empty and frozen.  The amount of damage did not matter because the floor needed a new and better implementation and the rain down the chimney onto the broken hearth had rotted the pipes which fed the entire floor in a single loop.

OldPipes14

There are several things to note about the original iron pipes creating the first radiant floor. The spacing of about a foot and the settling of the rocks around them led to a correctly diagnosed heat loss both due to the lack of insulation under it to keep the heat retained and the insulating air gap caused by the air gap. And to any who might say replacing it was extreme, this was just one of the places where there were bursts in the pipes from the two years it sat empty.

 

Window Wall

 

Two winters and all the moisture running down the windows over its life had produced dry rot in many places and there were these large single pane sections slipping into the wood frame leading to air leakage in gaps at the top of some. The house did have moisture issues. It was not uncommon to have a ¼ inch of frost form on the south window wall nightly. This was particularly true when the inside pool was a fish and water plant pool.

 

Sampleinside1982-10

33 years of deep frost developing nightly and washing down the single pane of glass had cause dry rot and after two years empty the glass had slipped into the wood in some places creating air gaps at the tops of the panes.

 

 

OuterWal1982-9

 

It was not limited to the inside alone. The window wall was beyond tired.

 

Roof

 

The roof was intact. We were lucky that two winters without heat in the house had not collected masses of snow on the roof and collapsed the house.  I call the wing tips the southern most parts of the inner crescent (the east and west ends) which creates the overhang. The roof structure failed to support them and by 1982 we had several inches of sag. It is interesting to add right now that the shape of the house and the size of the overhang were extremely functional in Wright’s design. The curve of the house maintained a portion of the house with direct solar contact all day allowing those areas to have maximum solar gain (angles deflect solar energy). Further, the overhang allowed full solar access to the entire house in the winter and no solar past the window wall in the summer. Spring and fall had transition amounts of solar energy.

 

15-Facia1982

They say a picture says 1000 words. The roof though, technically flat, had a very slight tilt to the rear. There was never anything done to protect the roof’s facia from all the runoffs. The water came off the roof to travel over and behind the facia. Of note in this photo is the concrete roof to the shop which has a block wall to the north and the back of the rear kitchen wall to the south. A door from the tunnel connects to this space which is open to the utility portion of the tower.

 

19-RoofComposition

As we were cutting in the new skylights, we got a very exact picture of the lack of any real insulation. The photo shows a bonded roof of two ½ in tongue and grove layers with ½ inch of some sort of particle board. We will come back later and focus on the final structure of the roof rafters and north wall supports as we get to those parts in the story.

 

Other Windows

 

Technically, with the storms everywhere (except the front window wall), the windows were not an energy problem though the energy audit did blame the collective windows other than the front wall as a 20% energy drain. They were a usability issue. There were three old style casement windows (Slot windows).  There was a job every spring to get the west slot windows open after removing the storms. There was a 3-4 foot one where the back wall of the house hit the kitchen wall along the tunnel that was not as hard as the 6’ ones in the slots.

 

Slot Windows

 

The two tall ones were very important as they scooped air from the south and the flow then went out the kitchen slot and the back upstairs awning windows. They were at the back of covered patio on the west end which tapered back to these windows. These three windows and the six awning windows were the only air source other than small transom windows over the east and west doors.

 

North Window Wall Windows

 

The bedroom windows were a whole other issue. There was a rod which was hinged to the window. There was a metal block attached to the inside window frame which this rod slid through. A small turn knob here let you stop the slide and hold the windows at various opening widths. The knob at the end was slightly smaller than a dime. It was very hard to close by pulling on this rod as they were always open all the way and this knob was against the slider hold hardware. To make matters worse, the windows had been hinged on the bottom having all the weight making it almost impossible to close them when they were in their normal open summer state. I cannot count the times I ran out in a storm to push them closed as the wind coming up the north berm would drive the rain up the berm and into the windows. One could not just grab that small knob at the end and pull against all that weight to close the window. The internal homemade screens were screwed on so that a quick pull of the windows from the inside was not possible.

 

Light in the House

 

As mentioned early on, the bedrooms (all five) were dark. This was in total contrast to how light and bright and sunny it was downstairs. This was mainly due to carving a walkway along the window wall side of the balcony. This had the original three partitioned bedrooms added by Herb Jacobs to have a full south wall blocking the window wall. The end rooms had stone walls wrap around them before the window wall started leaving them with indirect light from the window wall. It is important to note that it was mostly the partitioning of the upstairs which made it dark, not the design.

 

Pools

 

The house had reflecting pools which added another circle within the circles of the house. One of the things I did look at when I had the original plans (returned in 2019) was the pool design, as I made some changes during the restoration. Herb Jacobs operated as his own contractor as far as I know and changed things as he went. The designed furniture may be the only plywood Frank Lloyd Wright art pieces anywhere. The pools were to be a half sphere with a glass separation (as in each pool was to be a quarter sphere. A glass window to a Wisconsin winter simply made no sense. He made the inside pool about 1.5 feet deep with a pipe threaded into a ¾ inch drain to catch overflow and allow a way to empty it for cleaning. The outside pool he made into a plunge pool about 4 feet deep. There was a concrete wall between the pools holding that portion of the window wall. The important aspect has always been the circle of the pools intersecting the house in front as the tower intersects the house from the back.

 

As design elements, they were incredible but as maintenance issues they were a pain. The pipe feeding the pools had the faucet die and eventually the only way to fill it was turn in it on in the utility room in the tower and let it leak full. When we cleaned it to get the muck and gravel from pots out, we first had to set up a syphon with a hose to get it mostly empty. Then we had to use dust pans and a pail to get the rest of the muck, stones, and water out. I won’t even go into how to keep the outside pool nice with the same kind of fill pipe and pipe drain. There was no filter for it but we as a family set up a temporary filter which was always a joy to get going (I am being facetious here as we had to try to get water fully into the inflow pipe so it would restart) as the water drained from the pipes. Pumps don’t function well when all of it is on the walk above….

 

 

 

The roof

 

This one did not really surprise me in terms of needing a permanent fix.  The roof structure as built did not work and there were several inches of drop in both the east and west wing tips to the south over the covered patios and walkways. The damage, after years of water flowing off the front over the wing tips, was evidence that they had a slope contrary to the one where all the water was to drain to the north. The wing tips were the east and west ends of the south crescent formed as the roof design like the house was a segment of a donut shaped object. What did surprise me was that the house would not meet code unless the roof was strengthened. It had never had to hold a snow load (except the winters of 1980 and 1981). Then it sat empty and unheated except for the solar gain. It had always melted the snow. However, now, to meet code, the rafters had to be strengthened. This holding of snow was just one of the ways we needed to make the house more livable.